Wednesday, October 01, 2008

The Wisdom of Wallace Stegner: America and Robert Frost

I've long had a strong admiration for Wallace Stegner. Though not a professing Christian he had an obvious wisdom that was not co-opted by the tyrannies of the left or right. With that in mind I thought it'd be pertinent to blog on his thoughts on America, given the shape of it at late... Stegner writes:

Above all, let us not forget or mislay our optimism about the possible. In all our history we have never been more than a few years without a crisis, and some of those crises, the Civil War for one, and the whole problem of slavery, have been graver and more alarming than our present one. We have never stopped criticizing the performance of our elected leaders, and we have indeed had some bad ones and have survived them. The system was developed by accident and opportunity, but it is a system of extraordinary resilience. The United States has a ramshackle government, Robert Frost told Khrushchev in a notable conversation. The more you ram us, the harder we shackle. In the midst of our anxiety we should remember that this is the oldest and stablest republic in the world. Whatever its weaknesses and failures, we show no inclination to defect. The currents of defection flow the other way.

Let us not forget who we started out to be, or be surprised that we have not yet arrived. Robert Frost can again, as so often be our spokesman, "The land was ours before we were the land's," he wrote. "Something we were withholding made us weak, until we found that it was ourselves we were withholding from our land of living." He was a complex, difficult, often malicious man, with grave faults. He was also one of our great poets, as much in the American grain as Lincoln or Thoreau. He contained within himself many of our most contradictory qualities, he never learned to subdue his selfish personal demon--and he was never a favorite of the New York critics, who thought him a country bumpkin.

But like the folk mind, he was wiser than intellectuals. No American was ever wiser. Listening to him, we can refresh ourselves with our own best image, and renew our vision of America: not as Perfection, not as Heaven on Earth, not as New Jerusalem, but as flawed glory and exhilarating task.

1 comment:

mrteague said...


I like this. Good thoughts. Hey, it was good hanging out the other night.